Definitely watch it, but just once.
I won’t say the movie was a let down coz I know why I was going there. Aamir Khan. If you love this guy, for old times sakes, you must go and watch the movie. Considering the expectations it has generated the movie is not able to live up to them. My reaction was ‘BAS, ITNAHICH?’
Merits:
* Aamir Khan’s different look (he was even looking cute when he smiled thru those mooch)
* Aamir Khan’s acting (wasn’t much scope to act, he had to just give a flared up joshila look no matter wot the scene)
* The song – Mangala mangala
* Om puri’s narration gave us the hope that there is someone to guide thru the non-story and that we wont be lost
DeMerits:
* Ketan Mehta has failed to generate, maintain, accelerate any momentum to the movie. Everytime he reaches there and then diffuses the effect with some silly scene.
* There are those moments which you wish would be the hi-lite of the whole patriotic drama, but they are hesitantly missed everytime by the director.
* Unnecessary characters – Rani M, Amisha Patel, KirrrrronKher, if they needed to be, then their portrayal was very bad, some meaningful purpose could’ve been cooked up for those characters. Their clothes were not at all like those times, all the more they were vulgar.
* Silly dialogues at times.
* Unnecessary songs – tawaif song, dargaa song, gypsy song, holi song……and many more!!!! Sooooo many songs!! :( :( :(
* There was no flow to the movie, just some good patches put together.
-Y.